Search Coins

‘Lower tier’ exchanges exhibit high trading volume

eng.ambcrypto.com6 minutes ago
0

Do you want to win a €1,000 property investment whilst trading crypto? – Trade MPG on Stex & Probit

www.howtotoken.com21 minutes ago
0

Japan’s Third Largest Bank Completes Blockchain Trade Finance Test

www.coindesk.com39 minutes ago
0

4 Cryptocurrency Projects That Successfully Changed Chains

news.bitcoin.com39 minutes ago
0

Economic Inequality Triggers Chaos and Violence in Chile: Multiple Deaths, Trains Torched, Banks Closed, Buildings Burned

dailyhodl.coman hour ago
0

CFTC Chairman Optimistic on Launch of Ethereum Futures and other Crypto Derivatives

coingape.com3 hours ago
0

Banking Scandals, Money Printing and the Anti-Bribery Standard: A Strategic Approach in the Fight Against Corruption (ISO 37001)

dailyhodl.com3 hours ago
0

Running Bitcoin Cash: An Introduction to Operating a Full Node

news.bitcoin.com4 hours ago
0

Sally Ho's Technical Analysis 22 October 2019

cryptodaily.co.uk4 hours ago
0

A look at exchange confirmation times and settlement assurances

www.theblockcrypto.com5 hours ago
0

Facebook Considering Stablecoin Alternatives to Ensure Libra Launch

altcoin.media5 hours ago
0

Money 2.0 Stuff: The Facebook Start Up methodology

www.theblockcrypto.com6 hours ago
0

Coinbase, Poloniex and Other AA-Graded Crypto Exchanges Saw a 31% Plunge in Trading Volume in Sept – Report

coingape.com7 hours ago
0

How Would Bitcoin Fare in a ‘Growth Recession?’

altcoin.media7 hours ago
0

Michael Terpin Urges FCC to Curb Crypto Fraud That Cost Him $24 Million

www.coindesk.com7 hours ago
0

WATCH: UNICEF’s Crypto Fund Plans to Pay for Internet in Public Schools

www.coindesk.com7 hours ago
0

Former Fed Nominee Stephen Moore Backs Fractional Reserve Stablecoin

www.coindesk.com7 hours ago
0

Anti-Money Laundering Laws Apply to Crypto Too, Says FinCEN Chief

cointelegraph.com7 hours ago
0

How to Safely Store Your Wallet Recovery Phrase

news.bitcoin.com8 hours ago
0

A deep dive into Circle: What’s the game plan now that Poloniex has been axed

www.theblockcrypto.com8 hours ago
0

CFTC Chair Says Ether Futures ‘Likely’ in 2020

www.coindesk.com8 hours ago
0

WATCH: Ecash Creator David Chaum On His New ‘Quantum-Resistant’ Cryptocurrency, Praxxis

www.coindesk.com8 hours ago
0

Will Bermuda Be the New Crypto Center of the World?

www.livebitcoinnews.com9 hours ago
0

There Is Now Less Half a Bitcoin for Each Millionaire

altcoin.media9 hours ago
0

CFTC Chairman: a commodity can become a security and vice versa

www.theblockcrypto.com9 hours ago
0

Ethereum Hard Fork: How Important Is Backwards Compatibility?

Sep 7, 2019 12:10 PM +00:00
0

The Ethereum Foundation has delayed the testnet launch of the Istanbul update until the start of October. But some are raising concerns about one of the Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs) which will break certain smart contracts. So should technology be backward compatible ad infinitum?… or is a little disruption necessary in the name of progress?


Too Many EIPs Delay The Upgrade

The testnet activation of the latest update was originally due to happen on September 4th. However, the date has been pushed back to the start of October due to a large number of EIPs submitted for review. Developers eventually accepted six of these for inclusion in the Istanbul package, with a further eight in the following upgrade.

The testnet delay means that the mainnet activation will also occur a month later, in November after the DevCon developer conference.

Breaking Ethereum’s Contract

However, Parity developer, Wei Tang, has raised concerns about one of the improvement proposals, Ethereum Improvement Proposal 1884. This “will break at least a few deployed contracts,” he tweeted, continuing that “what worries me is that some participants on last AllCoreDevs seem to classify it as acceptable behavior.”

He goes on to say:

For software engineering, if you’re developing something that many people depends on, then backward compatibility is one of the top priorities for making any design decisions. This is especially important for blockchain, because a lot of money can be involved.

The technical details of the compatibility issues can be found on GitHub.

You Can’t Make An Omelette Without Breaking Eggs

While Tang’s concerns may seem valid, there is, of course, a counter-argument that obsessing over backward compatibility is counteractive to progress.

Tang makes the example of Microsoft’s Windows gaining popularity because of backward compatibility. Whilst it may have gained popularity in this period, it arguably fell into a technological black-hole.

Apple’s insistence on allowing old-tech to fall into obsolescence was (and still is) widely criticized. However, it took Microsoft years and many iterations of Windows before it caught up to the advances of Apple’s OS X, losing backward compatibility on the way.

If it were purely down to Microsoft, we would likely still be lugging around laptops with legacy VGA and serial ports. Slimline, slimline!

With concerns as to how much space is left on the Ethereum blockchain, clearly something must be done or technology could die. With stakes that high, surely a few broken contracts are a small price to pay?

What do you think about the disputed Ethereum Improvement Proposal? Comment below.


Image via Shutterstock

The post Ethereum Hard Fork: How Important Is Backwards Compatibility? appeared first on Bitcoinist.com.

Share This Article


Get the most out of CoinFi News!

Save coins into your Watchlist and be the first to know about the latest market moving news.