Search Coins

NFT Collection The Superlative Secret Society Price, Stats, and Review

cryptodaily.co.ukin 3 years
-2

Ethena Labs reportedly suffers from security incident, analysts suspect $290k exploit

crypto.news5 minutes ago
0

UK Judge Freezes $7.6 Million of Craig Wright’s Assets Worldwide

coingape.com9 minutes ago
0

Demystifying EU crypto legislation, insights from former Icelandic Central Bank chairman

crypto.news12 minutes ago
0

The Robinhood Custodial Account. What Is It, and How Does It Work?

coindoo.com41 minutes ago
0

Crypto Analyst Predicts Top 8 Altcoins With 50x Potential Not Yet On Binance

www.newsbtc.coman hour ago
0

‘Bitcoin a better investment than MicroStrategy’ – Is it really?

ambcrypto.coman hour ago
0

Breaking: PCE Inflation Comes In Hot At 2.5%, Bitcoin Price to Drop?

coingape.coman hour ago
0

Raffle Coin targets 50x surge; Polkadot, TRON, investors join presale

crypto.newsan hour ago
0

Solana Foundation Says It Can Filter Through the Offensive Meme Coin Problem

www.coindesk.coman hour ago
0

Jito (JTO) poised near key level; Is breakout to new all-time high next?

coinjournal.netan hour ago
0

XRP Lawyer Backs Judge Torres Deeming Ex-SEC Official’s Statement ‘Incorrect’

coingape.coman hour ago
0

Bitcoin Technical Analysis: BTC Consolidation Points to Potential Shifts Ahead

news.bitcoin.com2 hours ago
0

Solana-fueled ‘memecoins to billions’ – Here’s what this exec has to say

ambcrypto.com2 hours ago
0

Underdogs Defy Odds, Shaking up NCAA Tournament Brackets

news.bitcoin.com2 hours ago
0

Ethereum Spot ETFs Odds At A Pessimistic 25%: Bloomberg Analyst

bitcoinist.com2 hours ago
0

Bitget Wallet Secures the Top Spot Globally in Swap Transactions, Surpassing MetaMask

coinjournal.net2 hours ago
0

Crypto Analyst Says Mid-Cap Memecoin Primed To ‘Absolutely Rip,’ Updates Outlook on BNB and Dogecoin

dailyhodl.com2 hours ago
0

Kelexo challenges Aave; Ethereum, Cardano, investors join presale

crypto.news2 hours ago
0

Craig Wright Assets Frozen by UK Judge to Prevent Him Evading Court Costs

www.coindesk.com2 hours ago
0

UK, US Probe $20B in USDT Transfers by Sanctioned Russian Crypto Exchange

news.bitcoin.com2 hours ago
0

Dogecoin Jumps 37% – How High Can DOGE Go This April?

www.newsbtc.com2 hours ago
0

DeeStream captivates Litecoin, Chainlink investors

crypto.news3 hours ago
0

Bitwise CIO predicts $1T BTC inflow via ETFs from institutional investors

crypto.news3 hours ago
0

Analysts evaluate XRP and Polygon performance; highlight RECQ presale prospects

crypto.news3 hours ago
0

Ethereum Hard Fork: How Important Is Backwards Compatibility?

Sep 7, 2019 12:10 PM +00:00
0

The Ethereum Foundation has delayed the testnet launch of the Istanbul update until the start of October. But some are raising concerns about one of the Ethereum Improvement Proposals (EIPs) which will break certain smart contracts. So should technology be backward compatible ad infinitum?… or is a little disruption necessary in the name of progress?




Too Many EIPs Delay The Upgrade

The testnet activation of the latest update was originally due to happen on September 4th. However, the date has been pushed back to the start of October due to a large number of EIPs submitted for review. Developers eventually accepted six of these for inclusion in the Istanbul package, with a further eight in the following upgrade.


The testnet delay means that the mainnet activation will also occur a month later, in November after the DevCon developer conference.


Breaking Ethereum’s Contract

However, Parity developer, Wei Tang, has raised concerns about one of the improvement proposals, Ethereum Improvement Proposal 1884. This “will break at least a few deployed contracts,” he tweeted, continuing that “what worries me is that some participants on last AllCoreDevs seem to classify it as acceptable behavior.”


He goes on to say:


For software engineering, if you’re developing something that many people depends on, then backward compatibility is one of the top priorities for making any design decisions. This is especially important for blockchain, because a lot of money can be involved.


The technical details of the compatibility issues can be found on GitHub.


You Can’t Make An Omelette Without Breaking Eggs

While Tang’s concerns may seem valid, there is, of course, a counter-argument that obsessing over backward compatibility is counteractive to progress.


Tang makes the example of Microsoft’s Windows gaining popularity because of backward compatibility. Whilst it may have gained popularity in this period, it arguably fell into a technological black-hole.


Apple’s insistence on allowing old-tech to fall into obsolescence was (and still is) widely criticized. However, it took Microsoft years and many iterations of Windows before it caught up to the advances of Apple’s OS X, losing backward compatibility on the way.


If it were purely down to Microsoft, we would likely still be lugging around laptops with legacy VGA and serial ports. Slimline, slimline!


With concerns as to how much space is left on the Ethereum blockchain, clearly something must be done or technology could die. With stakes that high, surely a few broken contracts are a small price to pay?


What do you think about the disputed Ethereum Improvement Proposal? Comment below.




Image via Shutterstock


The post Ethereum Hard Fork: How Important Is Backwards Compatibility? appeared first on Bitcoinist.com.

Share This Article


Get the most out of CoinFi News!

Save coins into your Watchlist and be the first to know about the latest market moving news.